Tottenham are reportedly circling Morgan Gibbs-White again, more than a year after their first attempt to sign him collapsed in acrimonious fashion.
Nottingham Forest's response to that first approach was to make him their record earner rather than sell him, which is the backdrop against which any fresh interest now has to be judged.
Contents
1. Morgan Gibbs-White to Tottenham rated ‘Unlikely'2. Morgan Gibbs-White to Tottenham3. Financial viability4. Buying club need5. Player motivation6. Selling club incentive7. Market momentum8. Morgan Gibbs-White to Tottenham: Will or won't it happen?Morgan Gibbs-White to Tottenham rated ‘Unlikely'
The Football Whispers Index scores every transfer rumour across five weighted factors. Read how it works here.
Football Whispers Index: Transfer predictorMorgan Gibbs-White to Tottenham
37/100 TPI Unlikely Forest handed Gibbs-White a new contract to 2028 and made him their top earner, which is why Tottenham's reported £125m interest sits in Unlikely. Updated 21 September 2026 Financial viability14 / 25 Buying club need15 / 20 Player motivation6 / 15 Selling club incentive2 / 20 Market momentum6 / 20A score of 37 sits in Unlikely, and the gap between the two strongest pillars and the two weakest is the story here.
Tottenham's need is obvious and Gibbs-White's numbers back it up, which is why Buying club need is the highest-scoring pillar on the board.
But Forest's incentive to sell is close to the bottom of the scale, because the club have already made their position clear with a new contract rather than a price tag, and that single fact drags the score down more than any transfer fee could.
Financial viability
Financial viability14 / 25 Tottenham are working from a reported £125m valuation for Gibbs-White, more than double the £60m release clause they tried to trigger for him in July 2025. Gibbs-White signed a new contract at the City Ground running to 30 June 2028 that made him Nottingham Forest's highest earner. Tottenham have already committed more than £400m in the summer transfer window before turning back to Gibbs-White. Forest recently sold Elliot Anderson to Manchester City, easing the pressure on their books.The number that matters most here is the jump from £60m to £125m in the space of little more than a year.
That is not simply market inflation, it is Forest re-pricing their own most important player after watching Tottenham try to take him once already.
Spurs also come into this having already spent heavily over the summer, which makes a second nine-figure outlay in the same financial year a genuinely different proposition to last year's release-clause raid.
Forest, for their part, do not need the money, having already banked a significant fee for Elliot Anderson without having to touch their best player.
Buying club need
Buying club need15 / 20 Xavi Simons, Tottenham's first-choice attacking midfielder, is out with a cruciate ligament injury and not expected back until early February 2027. Gibbs-White scored 15 Premier League goals last season, more than Simons, James Maddison and Dejan Kulusevski managed between them in the same role. Roberto De Zerbi's side have managed a total expected goals figure of just 4.47 in the Premier League this season. Gibbs-White has 34 goals and 35 assists in 196 top-flight appearances since joining Forest from Wolves in 2022.This is the strongest case Tottenham have, and it is built on more than a hunch.
Losing Xavi Simons to injury for the rest of the calendar year leaves a real hole in the position Gibbs-White plays, not a squad-depth quibble that gets solved by shuffling Maddison or Kulusevski a few yards forward.
Spurs' underlying attacking numbers this season are thin enough that the gap is visible in the results, not just the team sheet.
Gibbs-White's own career output, built over four seasons in the Premier League, is exactly the kind of proven end product that a struggling attack tends to go looking for in January.
Player motivation
Player motivation6 / 15 Gibbs-White has been the Premier League's leading scorer of the 2026 calendar year, a run that included a hat-trick against Burnley and another in Forest's 5-0 win over Sunderland. He is Nottingham Forest's highest earner on £140,000 a week under the new contract he signed after Tottenham's 2025 approach. Forest owner Evangelos Marinakis threatened legal action when Tottenham tried to sign Gibbs-White for £60m in 2025. He earned senior England recognition under both Lee Carsley and Thomas Tuchel on the back of his form for Forest.Everything here points toward a player with little obvious reason to force his way out.
Gibbs-White is not a fringe player nursing a grievance, he has been the Premier League's outstanding attacking midfielder of the calendar year, the kind of form that tends to deepen a player's standing at his current club rather than push him toward the exit.
He is also already the best-paid player at Forest, which removes one of the usual levers a bigger club can pull.
The last time Tottenham tried to sign him, the fallout was public and ugly enough that Marinakis threatened legal action, and Gibbs-White's answer was to sign a new deal rather than push for a move, which tells its own story about where his loyalties currently sit.
Selling club incentive
Selling club incentive2 / 20 Gibbs-White signed his new Forest contract shortly after the club rejected Tottenham's £60m approach in the summer of 2025. Forest have sold Elliot Anderson and Anthony Elanga for a combined £110m across recent windows without losing Gibbs-White. No replacement for Gibbs-White's role has been reported at the City Ground.This is the pillar that does the most damage to Tottenham's chances, and it is not close.
A club that wanted to eventually cash in on a player does not usually respond to a rival's approach by tying him down for three more years and making him the top earner in the building.
Forest have shown, with Anderson and Elanga, that they are perfectly willing to sell when it suits them, which makes the absence of any such move for Gibbs-White even more pointed rather than incidental.
And with no replacement lined up for his role, there is no sign Forest are even quietly preparing for the possibility.
Market momentum
Market momentum6 / 20 The £125m valuation comes from a single Football Insider report, carried onward by outlets including the BBC's gossip column, Goal and ESPN. Football Insider journalist Pete O'Rourke said Forest's handling of the 2025 approach “showed how much faith” the club has in Gibbs-White. Tottenham's interest was first tested in July 2025, when the £60m release-clause move collapsed under threat of legal action.Volume is not the same as confirmation, and that distinction matters here.
The story has travelled widely, but every version of it traces back to the same Football Insider report, which means the £125m figure and the January framing have not yet been independently stood up by a second newsroom.
What is genuinely established is the history: Tottenham's interest is real and dates back to a serious, failed attempt in 2025, so this is not a rumour appearing from nowhere.
It is a rumour that needs a second, independent source before it can be treated as anything more than Tottenham's known admiration resurfacing again.
Morgan Gibbs-White to Tottenham: Will or won't it happen?
The verdict37 / 100 Forest have just handed Gibbs-White a new contract and lean on him as their top scorer, which is why this sits in Unlikely despite Tottenham's obvious creative need. It happens if Spurs' attacking struggles persist into January and they table an actual bid that tests Forest's resolve. It dies if Forest, flush from selling Elliot Anderson and with no financial need, simply refuse to sell their record signing and highest earner.Nothing about this rumour suggests Tottenham have gone cold on Gibbs-White, and nothing about Forest's summer suggests they have gone cold on keeping him either.
For this to move from Unlikely toward Possible, watch for two things: a second outlet independently confirming the £125m figure, and any sign that Spurs' attacking numbers are bad enough in December to force a genuine bid rather than another round of interest.
Until then, a club that pays its main creative outlet more than anyone else in the building is not a club preparing to sell him.
Hence then, the article about will tottenham sign morgan gibbs white why mammoth 125m transfer is unlikely in january football whispers index score was published today ( ) and is available on Football Whispers ( Middle East ) The editorial team at PressBee has edited and verified it, and it may have been modified, fully republished, or quoted. You can read and follow the updates of this news or article from its original source.
Read More Details
Finally We wish PressBee provided you with enough information of ( Will Tottenham sign Morgan Gibbs-White? Why mammoth £125m transfer is ‘Unlikely’ in January – Football Whispers Index score )
Also on site :
- Latest transfer news today: Man City and Liverpool to battle for La Liga full-back as Arsenal prepare to sell £55m man
- SwimOutlet Has a New App. Can It Make Buying Swim Gear Easier?
- Penalties cost Jets what could’ve been signature win over struggling Packers