Pumpkin and pecan pies might get most of the attention at Thanksgiving, but they’re hardly the only desserts worth making room for. Across the country, families have their own holiday favorites, including a few regional specialties that rarely appear on menus elsewhere.In Southern Indiana, one of those traditions involves a small, orange fruit that grows wild throughout the region. It’s gathered in the fall, turned into a sweet pulp and baked into a dessert that’s been passed down through generations of Hoosier families.The result is persimmon pudding, a rich, spiced dessert that looks more like a moist cake than the creamy pudding most Americans are familiar with. And for families who grew up eating it, Thanksgiving wouldn’t be quite the same without it.Related: 65+ Classic Thanksgiving Recipes, From Savory to Sweet and Everything in Between
What Is Persimmon Pudding?
Persimmon pudding is a traditional baked dessert made with ripe persimmon pulp, flour, sugar, eggs, milk or buttermilk, and warm spices such as cinnamon and allspice.Despite its name, it isn’t particularly similar to the smooth, creamy pudding you might find in the refrigerated section of a grocery store. Instead, Indiana-style persimmon pudding has a dense, moist texture that falls somewhere between a soft cake and a traditional English pudding. Its dark brown color and rich consistency make it especially distinctive. The flavor is sweet and gently spiced, with the persimmons adding a subtle fruitiness that complements the other ingredients.According to Purdue University’s Department of Horticulture, the American persimmon grows wild throughout much of Southern Indiana, where its fruit has long been prized for use in desserts.While recipes vary from one household to another, the basic preparation remains fairly consistent. Ripe persimmons are processed into pulp, combined with the remaining ingredients and baked until the pudding develops its characteristic texture.It’s traditionally served on its own or with a generous spoonful of whipped cream.Related: 24 Retro-Inspired Thanksgiving Recipes That Deserve a Comeback
Why Is Persimmon Pudding So Popular in Southern Indiana?
The Washington Post / Getty Images
Much of persimmon pudding’s regional popularity comes down to the availability of its most important ingredient.The American persimmon (Diospyros virginiana) is native to the eastern United States and grows naturally in Southern Indiana. Its fruit ripens during the fall, making it a convenient ingredient for seasonal baking.But there’s an important catch: Persimmons need to be fully ripe before they’re eaten.As Purdue Extension explains, unripe American persimmons contain tannins that produce an intensely astringent sensation in the mouth. Once the fruit softens and ripens, however, it becomes remarkably sweet.Traditionally, families would gather ripe persimmons, remove their seeds and skins, and save the pulp for baking. The practice remains familiar to many Southern Indiana residents today.In a 2022 report from Indiana Public Media, Bloomington resident Susan Gray shared a persimmon pudding recipe passed down from Clara Kinsey, the wife of Indiana University researcher Alfred Kinsey. Gray described making the pudding for family Thanksgiving and Christmas celebrations, illustrating how closely the dessert is connected to holiday traditions.For many families, it’s more than something sweet to serve after dinner. It’s a recipe that connects one generation to the next.
Southern Indiana’s Annual Persimmon Festival
If there’s any doubt about Southern Indiana’s affection for persimmons, the town of Mitchell offers plenty of evidence. Located in Lawrence County, Mitchell has celebrated the fruit with an annual Persimmon Festival since 1947.
The event includes entertainment, food vendors, a parade and other community activities. But one of its most recognizable traditions is the persimmon pudding competition, where local bakers submit their favorite recipes.
According to Visit Indiana, the competition is a centerpiece of the festival, attracting participants eager to demonstrate their baking skills. The event also highlights just how personal these recipes can be.
In an episode of PBS’s Journey Indiana, 2021 pudding competition winner Jane Root explained that her recipe came from her mother-in-law. She also emphasized the importance of using fully ripe fruit and avoiding overbaking.
It’s the kind of regional food tradition where nearly everyone seems to have a favorite recipe, and small differences can inspire plenty of friendly debate.Related: 22 Easy Yet Elegant Holiday Dessert Recipes
What Makes Persimmon Pudding Different From Pumpkin Pie?
Although both desserts feature warm spices and seasonal ingredients, persimmon pudding and pumpkin pie are quite different.
Pumpkin pie typically has a smooth, custard-like filling baked inside a pastry crust. Persimmon pudding, on the other hand, is baked without a crust and has a denser, more cake-like consistency.
The flavor is different, too. While pumpkin pie relies heavily on the combination of pumpkin and spices, persimmon pudding gets much of its sweetness and character from the ripe fruit itself.
There are also variations in how people prepare and serve it.
The University of Southern Indiana has published a traditional Indiana-style recipe featuring persimmon pulp, buttermilk, eggs, brown sugar, cinnamon and allspice. The finished pudding is served with whipped cream. Some families enjoy it warm, while others prefer it after it has cooled.
Neither dessert is necessarily better than the other. But for anyone accustomed to seeing the same pies every Thanksgiving, persimmon pudding offers something different.
Can You Make Persimmon Pudding at Home?
Yes! You don’t have to live in Southern Indiana to try this regional favorite, although finding the right persimmons can require a little planning.
Traditional recipes generally call for American persimmons, which are much smaller than many of the Asian varieties commonly found in supermarkets. The fruit should be extremely soft and fully ripe before it’s processed into pulp.
According to Penn State Extension, ripe American persimmons can be pressed through a food mill or fine colander to separate the edible pulp from the skin and seeds. If fresh American persimmons aren’t available, prepared frozen pulp may be another option. Some Southern Indiana stores sell it specifically for baking, as documented by PBS.Related: 56 Mini Thanksgiving Dessert Recipes To Ensure Everyone Has Room for Dessert
How To Make Persimmon Pudding
For an authentic starting point, the University of Southern Indiana’s recipe provides measured ingredients and baking instructions. Here’s how to make it at home.
Ingredients Needed for Indiana-Style Persimmon Pudding
1 cup of sugar (white) 1 cup sugar, dark brown, packed 2 1/4 cups of flour 1 tablespoon of baking powder 1 teaspoon of soda 1 teaspoon of cinnamon 1 teaspoon of allspice 1/2 teaspoon of salt 2 cups of persimmon pulp 1 cup of buttermilk 2 eggsDirections
Before getting started, preheat your oven to 350°F. Then, in a large mixing bowl, combine all your ingredients. Mix them at low speed with a blender, beating the ingredients until the batter is smooth. Once mixed, pour the batter into the prepared pans and smooth it with a spatula. Bake for 60 minutes. Enjoy!
Will Persimmon Pudding Replace Pumpkin Pie at Thanksgiving?
While persimmon pudding might never replace pumpkin pie on every Thanksgiving table, it’s easy to see why this regional favorite has endured. For generations of Southern Indiana families, the familiar taste of sweet persimmons and warm spices has been part of what makes the holiday feel like home.
Related: The Ultimate Dessert Debate: Is Cake Actually Better Than Pie?
This article was drafted with the assistance of AI and thoroughly reviewed, edited and fact-checked by Parade editors. See our complete AI Policy.
Hence then, the article about move over pumpkin pie southern indiana has a thanksgiving dessert most americans have never tried was published today ( ) and is available on Parade ( Saudi Arabia ) The editorial team at PressBee has edited and verified it, and it may have been modified, fully republished, or quoted. You can read and follow the updates of this news or article from its original source.
Read More Details
Finally We wish PressBee provided you with enough information of ( Move Over, Pumpkin Pie: Southern Indiana Has a Thanksgiving Dessert Most Americans Have Never Tried )
Also on site :
- In 1886, a Father-Son Duo Patented the Process for Making This Chef-Approved Salt—140 Years Later, the Brand Is Celebrating By Launching Its First-Ever Cookbook
- Neon-Backed Biopic ‘Caesar,’ About Syrian Officer Who Blew the Whistle on Assad Regime Torture, to Be Directed by Ameer Fakher Eldin
- Walmart’s $20 Ribbed Long-Sleeve Loungewear Set Is ‘Soft’ and ‘Stylish’ Enough to Wear on Christmas Day
