YOUNGSTOWN – A federal judge dismissed a $30 million lawsuit from a Stark County couple who contended they were injured while being removed from President Donald Trump’s Oct. 12 Youngstown rally after shouting in the direction of outgoing U.S. Sen. Jon Husted.
Judge Benita Y. Pearson dismissed the case Wednesday after the couple failed to pay the $405 filing fee or submit the proper applications to show they were indigent and couldn’t afford the expense.
Pearson denied the woman’s motion to proceed without paying the fee on Nov. 10 and gave the unnamed couple – called John and Jane Doe in the lawsuit and from East Canton – seven days to file the request.
The judge wrote in Wednesday’s decision: “To date, the plaintiffs have failed to respond. Accordingly, the matter is dismissed without prejudice.”
The couple can choose to refile the lawsuit.
The lawsuit was filed Oct. 28 naming Husted, the city of Youngstown, Mahoning County Sheriff Jerry Greene, four unknown sheriff deputies and Ironwood Protection Group as defendants.
Pearson on Nov. 5 rejected the couple’s motion for a temporary restraining order.
Pearson rejected the woman’s request to not pay the $405 on Nov. 10 and three days later, the judge informed the couple’s attorney, Leah J. Sellers of Gahanna, that she had seven days to register to practice before the court. The latter became moot with the case dismissed.
In the woman’s application to not pay the court fee, filled out by Sellers, she listed $3,400 in monthly income, including $540 in public assistance, and then later $3,120 in income and $3,960 in monthly expenses.
The application listed John Doe’s monthly income as $200 first and then $8.30.
The application also checked the “no” box on the question: “Have you spent – or will you be spending – any money for expenses or attorney fees in conjunction with this lawsuit?”
In her Nov. 10 order, Pearson wrote the “application contains inconsistencies and questionable information. Having considered Jane Doe’s application, the court denies it.”
Pearson wrote the husband didn’t file an application.
The judge added: “While pauper status does not require absolute destitution, the court must be able to examine the affidavit and determine whether the litigants can pay court costs without undue hardship. Based on the information provided, the court cannot determine that plaintiffs qualify for pauper status. Plaintiffs are reminded that by signing their applications, they ‘declare under penalty of perjury that the information below is true and understand that a false statement may result in a dismissal of (their) claims.’”
The lawsuit had claimed that during Husted’s speech at the Covelli Centre, John Doe yelled, “Pedophile protector,” among other things at the senator. The lawsuit states: “Jane Doe also vocalized her dissent.”
The couple claimed they were injured by security and law enforcement, which Sheriff Jerry Greene vehemently denied.
Told Thursday that the case was dismissed, Greene said, “I’m extremely confident that our deputies acted appropriately.”
In another matter involving the same Trump rally, sheriff Chief Deputy Jeff Allen met Thursday with Kathleen Thompson, Youngstown city prosecutor, to provide her with the department’s findings into an alleged assault of a female protestor at the event.
The sheriff’s department identified the victim and three men – two from the area and one from New Jersey – who were allegedly involved in the altercation. Videos show that at least one man punched the woman, who came forward as Blake Miley, in the face and pulled her hair.
The investigation determined one of the local men did not harm Miley.
It will be up to Thompson to file misdemeanor assault charges against any of the men.
Allen said Thompson requested a little follow-up and to come back to her with further information during the first or second week of December.
The sheriff’s office has been unable to contact the New Jersey man, identified as Russell Dickert.
Dickert lives too far away to be picked up for a misdemeanor charge, if any are filed. If Dickert is charged, a warrant block could be placed on his driver’s license that would not permit him to renew it when the current one expires unless he comes forward.
The alleged assault stopped when law enforcement officials arrived. Sheriff’s deputies removed Miley while the Trump supporters were permitted to remain at the rally.
When this occurred, Trump stopped speaking rather than trying to deescalate it.
As Miley was removed, and put up two middle fingers while being escorted out, Trump said: “He’s a paid protester. They’re all paid. They get paid by the lefties in order to destroy our country. They’re scum. But he’s going back home to mom.”
In addition to misidentifying her gender, Trump also made fun of her weight.
After being removed from the Covelli Centre, Miley drove herself to a local hospital.
Also stemming from the Trump rally in Youngstown, music legend Neil Young filed a $10 million federal lawsuit on Oct. 26 against the president’s Trump 47 Committee Inc. for the unauthorized use of his song “Rockin’ in the Free World” during that event as well as “numerous times at other rallies designed to encourage Republican votes in the upcoming midterm elections.”
The lawsuit states Trump “is now and at the time of all rallies this year was personally aware that a license would be required to play the song at rallies and that Young has not, and would not, grant the required license. In 2020, Young sued another corporation formed by Trump, Donald J. Trump for President Inc., for copyright infringement of ‘Rockin’ in the Free World’ along with another song written by Young (‘Devil’s Sidewalk’). Donald J. Trump for President Inc. asserted no defense and immediately settled shortly after it was served, promising that it would never again use ‘Rockin’ in the Free World’ without a license and permission from Young.”
A federal judge in that case in Virginia gave the Trump committee until Jan. 19, 2027, to respond to the complaint.
Hence then, the article about charges dismissed in trump rally lawsuit was published today ( ) and is available on TribToday ( Middle East ) The editorial team at PressBee has edited and verified it, and it may have been modified, fully republished, or quoted. You can read and follow the updates of this news or article from its original source.
Read More Details
Finally We wish PressBee provided you with enough information of ( Charges dismissed in Trump rally lawsuit )
Also on site :
- BeIN Media Group To Bring ‘Michael’, ‘Hamnet’ & ‘Jurassic World Rebirth’ To MENA Audiences With Fresh NBC Universal Deal
- Four States End Weight Loss Drug Coverage—What Happened Next Was Stark
- ‘The Day Of The Jackal’ Season 2 Teaser: Eddie Redmayne Leaps Back Into Action In Sky/Peacock Series