More than 150 years after Alexander Graham Bell received his patent for the telephone, a new book is reigniting controversy over who really invented the device—and the inventor’s descendants aren’t happy.
The Alexander and Mabel Bell Legacy Foundation, which represents the family’s historical legacy, is demanding corrections to The Telephone: A New History, a new book by bestselling author James Gleick.
The foundation issued a statement on Nov. 13 accusing the book of presenting disputed allegations about Bell’s invention as established facts, including claims involving theft and bribery.
But the book’s publisher, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, is standing behind Gleick’s work.
According to a Nov. 16 report from Publishers Weekly, the publisher defended the book’s research and rejected the foundation’s characterization of its historical account.
Why Alexander Graham Bell’s Family Is Challenging the New Book
In a statement published on its website, the Alexander and Mabel Bell Legacy Foundation said it strongly disputes portions of Gleick’s account of the telephone’s invention.
The organization argues that the book relies on questionable historical sources to suggest Bell obtained key elements of the invention through improper means.
One major point of disagreement involves Elisha Gray, another inventor who was developing telephone technology around the same time as Bell.
The foundation disputes the book’s account of Bell’s use of a liquid transmitter, arguing that historical documents demonstrate Bell had developed the relevant concept before Gray recorded a similar idea.
It also challenges allegations involving patent examiner Zenas Fisk Wilber, whose later statements became part of the long-running controversy surrounding Bell’s patent.
According to the foundation, Gleick’s book does not adequately explain the circumstances surrounding some of the historical testimony on which those allegations rely.
Sara Grosvenor, president of the foundation and a great-granddaughter of Alexander and Mabel Bell, expressed disappointment with the book’s portrayal of her ancestors.
“It’s profoundly disappointing to see a publisher widely promote this book’s sensationalized narrative to a broader audience while conclusive documentary evidence exists that refutes those allegations,” Grosvenor said in the statement.
The foundation says it has provided the publisher and author with a detailed account of what it considers factual errors and wants the disputed passages corrected in future printings.
Publisher Defends James Gleick’s ‘The Telephone’
Despite the objections from Bell’s descendants, Farrar, Straus and Giroux is defending the book.
In a statement provided to Publishers Weekly, the publisher said it stands behind Gleick’s work, describing the book as thoroughly researched and based on extensive historical documentation.
The publisher also pointed to the book’s endnotes and bibliography as evidence of Gleick’s commitment to historical accuracy.
Published in November, The Telephone: A New History explores the invention of the telephone and the technology’s enormous influence on communication, business and everyday life.
Gleick, a bestselling science and technology writer, is also known for books including The Information, Chaos and Time Travel.
The controversy surrounding Bell’s invention is hardly new. Historians have debated the competing claims, patent filings and testimony surrounding the telephone’s development for generations.
Bell received his landmark telephone patent in 1876, but questions about the contributions of other inventors and the circumstances surrounding the patent have continued to generate historical debate.
For now, Bell’s descendants and Gleick’s publisher remain at odds over how that history should be told.
The foundation wants changes to the book, while Farrar, Straus and Giroux maintains that its author’s research supports the account presented to readers.
Related: National Book Award Finalist Says He Was Denied a U.S. Visa Just Days Before Prestigious Ceremony
Hence then, the article about alexander graham bell s descendants demand corrections to new book claiming he stole the telephone publisher fires back was published today ( ) and is available on Parade ( Saudi Arabia ) The editorial team at PressBee has edited and verified it, and it may have been modified, fully republished, or quoted. You can read and follow the updates of this news or article from its original source.
Read More Details
Finally We wish PressBee provided you with enough information of ( Alexander Graham Bell’s Descendants Demand Corrections to New Book Claiming He Stole the Telephone—Publisher Fires Back )
Also on site :
- Germany vs Netherlands Live: Date, Time and Broadcasting Channel
- CFTC and Justice Department sue Arkansas and Louisiana over event-contract crackdowns
- We Asked Travel Advisors the Safest International Destination for First-Time Retiree Travelers—One Country Kept Coming Up
