Parade aims to feature only the best products and services. If you buy something via one of our links, we may earn a commission.
There's one pantry staple in particular that I rely on so much that its absence genuinely threw off my entire routine. When it vanished from Costco shelves earlier this year, I found myself scanning every aisle during every trip, hoping it would magically reappear. Fans online were doing the same, swapping theories, sharing updates and wondering if our go-to favorite was gone for good. After months of near silence, the Kirkland favorite is slowly reappearing at Costco.
? SIGN UP to get delicious recipes, handy kitchen hacks & fun food news in our daily Pop Kitchen newsletter ?
In September 2025, Costco quietly pulled a beloved Kirkland Signature staple, the Kirkland creamy peanut butter, from its lineup without warning. In its place, shoppers found a new option with a similar ingredient list but a completely different label, leading many to assume the original had been discontinued. The switch coincided with prior instances when Costco temporarily discontinued fan favorites due to supplier changes or inventory rotations, but this time felt different. Customer frustration escalated quickly, fueled by a lack of clarity and the fear that this wasn't just a seasonal reset.
The replacement product, Naturally More Organic Peanut Butter, uses only peanuts and salt, which earned it points with shoppers who prefer ultra-simple ingredients. But longtime fans of the Kirkland version missed its familiar texture and flavor, and social media lit up with complaints from people who had stocked up or switched stores trying to find the original. For many of us, the new option simply wasn't the same.
The Slow Return Fans Have Been Waiting For
View this post on InstagramWhile Costco never issued an official explanation, the disappearance followed the pattern of previous temporary pullbacks tied to supplier shortages and contract rotations. Those who remembered similar shake-ups in past years held onto hope that the popular item would quietly return once logistics settled. And now, months later, that whisper of hope is finally paying off.
Related: Costco's New $17 Treats Assortment Is a Must-Have for Holiday Gatherings
According to a recent Instagram post from @costco_empties, the beloved Kirkland peanut butter is beginning to show up again in select locations. The rollout appears to be extremely limited so far, but the sighting alone was enough to reignite excitement among fans who have been refreshing Reddit threads and revisiting warehouse aisles since the fall. It's not a full comeback yet, but it's the first real sign of movement after months of speculation.
As someone who kept checking aisle after aisle, hoping for the familiar red lid to return, this news feels like a small holiday miracle. If you've been missing it, too, keep an eye out for your next warehouse run.
Related: This New Costco Dessert Might Be Their Best One Yet
Hence then, the article about costco is quietly restocking a cult favorite kirkland staple after months of speculation was published today ( ) and is available on Parade ( Saudi Arabia ) The editorial team at PressBee has edited and verified it, and it may have been modified, fully republished, or quoted. You can read and follow the updates of this news or article from its original source.
Read More Details
Finally We wish PressBee provided you with enough information of ( Costco Is Quietly Restocking a Cult-Favorite Kirkland Staple After Months of Speculation )
Also on site :
- My Daughter’s Friend Has a Crush on My Husband. It’s Making Us Both Deeply Uncomfortable.
- Maga’s biggest fear is coming true and Trump won’t survive it
- Manchester United vs Newcastle Prediction: Heavyweights Meet in Premier League’s Only Boxing Day Clash