Mets fans showed up big in this week’s Mailbag inbox, so we’ll tackle multiple questions on the Amazins before looking at trade values for Baltimore’s Jackson Holliday and Pittsburgh’s Carmen Mlodzinski, as well as the Atlanta bullpen and Cleveland’s first base outlook. (Note: questions are lightly edited for brevity and clarity)
Let’s get into it!
Coach Wall asks:
The Mets obviously need a first baseman and need to get rid of Jorge Polanco (too much bad juju). The rumors are Ty France or Alec Bohm. Besides Andrew Vaughn, any other right handed hitting first baseman who might be available?
Jared asks:
Can the Mets just sign Ty France and get it over with? 2/32, 3/45 maybe (I have little faith in our minor league 1b). Brings defense, a bat, and a veteran at first, something I like.
Abner asks:
Beyond a hypothetical Tarik Skubal signing, what other pitchers could the NY Mets bring in to make the pitching staff an appropriate one for a contending MLB team? Also, I would like to know who could be a good fit for the 1B unsolved issue (after the horrible decision of letting Pete Alonso walk).
Chris asks:
Aside from the Mets being a player in the Skubal sweepstakes, I have seen a variety of sites/sources speculate on trades for starting pitchers. Two names that I have seen come up multiple times are Reid Detmers and Nick Lodolo. What would a Mets package for each look like?
That’s a bunch of Mets questions but isn’t even the entirety of what was on the mind of fans out in Queens. Rather than going through each individually, I’ll take these in totality to look ahead to some of the Mets’ looming decisions.
We’ll start with the biggest question of all: Skubal. I picked the Mets to sign him in our Free Agent Prediction Contest and still feel good about that. Skubal reportedly wants a long-term deal that locks him into one team for the remainder of his career (or the majority of it), which takes the Dodgers’ typical shorter-term free agent approach off the table. (Their long-term deals for Yoshinobu Yamamoto and Mookie Betts came with both players still in their mid-20s; Shohei Ohtani was 30, but he’s a unicorn case.)
Between the Mets, Jays and Padres, New York feels like the best candidate to make a monumental offer. Toronto already has Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Dylan Cease signed to huge long-term contracts. That’s not to say they couldn’t add another, but signing Skubal would mean committing to paying around $100MM per year to the Guerrero/Skubal/Cease trio through 2032 and then paying Guerrero and Skubal some $80MM+ per year for the remaining years of Skubal’s theoretical contract. Certainly not impossible, but it’s a pretty onerous long-term slate if they take that plunge.
All of that’s even more true of the Padres, who have Fernando Tatis Jr., Xander Bogaerts, Manny Machado and Jackson Merrill all signed through at least 2033. The Friars are already committed to $117MM in guaranteed money as far down the road as 2033. Do they want to push that number to $160MM+?
The Mets have Francisco Lindor for five more years. Juan Soto is signed through 2039, though his contract does contain an opt-out after the 2029 season. (I’m not sure a 31-year-old Soto is walking away from the remaining ten years and $460MM on that deal — and the Mets could negate it by bumping his annual salary by $4MM anyhow — but it’s at least a marginal possibility that he departs.) We can’t say that the trade of Brandon Nimmo and the decision to let Pete Alonso walk were in preparation for making this sort of run at Skubal, but those decisions did clean the long-term books and do help their cause in this pursuit.
If the Mets don’t get Skubal, it’ll be incumbent upon them to find other rotation upgrades. The Rays have said they intend to hang onto Drew Rasmussen. The Mets would be wise to try to change their minds. If not him, Reid Detmers is the top controllable arm on the market (arb-eligible through 2028). Frankly, either of those names should be in consideration even if the Mets do emerge victorious in the Skubal bidding. What might they cost? Let’s dig in a bit.
Finish This Article
Subscribe to keep reading and unlock all Front Office benefits.
$34.99 / year
BEST VALUEJust $2.92/month
Annually
$3.99 / month
Billed monthly
Monthly
UNLOCK FRONT OFFICE UNLOCK FRONT OFFICE100% Money-Back Guarantee
Explore All Front Office Benefits
Exclusive Articles & Analysis
Unlimited access to subscriber-only articles from our expert MLB writers.
Ad-Free Reading Experience
Enjoy faster, distraction-free browsing across MLB Trade Rumors, Hoops Rumors, Pro Football Rumors, Pro Hockey Rumors, and the Trade Rumors app.
GM-Caliber Research Tools
Explore our industry-leading MLB Payroll Tracker, Contract Tracker, Agency Database, and GM Tracker, with exclusive data and insights.
Live Subscriber Chats
Ask our MLB experts your burning hot stove questions in live chats.
Hence then, the article about mlb mailbag mets holliday pirates braves guardians was published today ( ) and is available on MLBtraderumors ( Middle East ) The editorial team at PressBee has edited and verified it, and it may have been modified, fully republished, or quoted. You can read and follow the updates of this news or article from its original source.
Read More Details
Finally We wish PressBee provided you with enough information of ( MLB Mailbag: Mets, Holliday, Pirates, Braves, Guardians )
Also on site :