Spain Built the Youth Development Pathway England Still Crave ...Middle East

News by : (The Analyst) -

Spain have won successive major international men’s tournaments. The pathways from academy football to senior teams at La Liga clubs has undoubtedly helped.

Drastic, nationwide reviews of football development in specific countries are ordinarily associated with prolonged fallow periods or short spells of extreme underperformance.

Two relatively recent high-profile examples would be Germany and England.

For Germany, a disappointing quarter-final exit to Croatia at the 1998 World Cup proved a pivotal moment for a re-think and increased investment behind the scenes in youth football. So, when there was outrage and calls for root-and-branch investigations in the wake of the national team failing to get out of their group at Euro 2000, strides had actually already been made. Germany went on to finish as runners-up at the 2002 World Cup, third at both the 2006 and 2010 World Cups, before winning it in 2014.

England, meanwhile, failed to even qualify for Euro 2008, and that was followed by an exit to Germany in the last 16 of a thoroughly underwhelming 2010 World Cup campaign. About six months after the latter, the FA unveiled its Youth Development Review, which provided 25 recommendations intended to improve the standard of football at every level, but especially in the grassroots game.

This review is broadly accepted as being a major catalyst for England’s significantly improved results at major men’s international tournaments in recent times, with the Three Lions reaching as many semi-finals (4) across the World Cup and European Championship since 2018 as they had in their entire history before Russia 2018.

How does any of this relate to Spain, then?

Well, if you’re looking for similarities with respect to underperformance, it doesn’t really relate at all, and that’s the point.

Over several years, Spain did their own review of youth development and is currently in the second phase of a 10-to-12-year La Liga-led National Plan for the Optimisation and Improvement of Youth Academies, essentially a strategy to professionalise them. But as Juan Florit, La Liga’s head of football projects, explains, academy reform in Spain was different to the prior examples because it was not triggered by a crisis.

“Traditionally, when a country, an organisation such as La Liga or a football association begins such a project, you start it from a position of weakness, from a problem or from a negative situation,” he says when asked by Opta Analyst about the initiative’s grounding. “But if we think that with this it will be enough for the first decade, sooner or later we will be behind other countries [again].”

In 2016, clubs from the top two divisions began hosting annual Youth Academy Meetings with the intention of sharing knowledge, methodology and tools, hoping to improve competitiveness.

Granted, at this point Spain had recently underwhelmed at Euro 2016, having also failed to impress at the 2014 World Cup. But still, this was only four years on from winning Euro 2012, their third successive triumph at a major international tournament. Spanish football was hardly in crisis.

The Youth Academy Meetings ultimately led to the 2022 creation of the aforementioned ‘National Plan’, which set out to take “grassroots football to a new level”.

It comprised five key principles: infrastructure, resources and technology; comprehensive player care; development and transition to professional football; training model and transition to competition; and structure and professional development.

This wasn’t a reaction to any extreme underperformance either. The senior side had got to the semis of the delayed Euro 2020 a year earlier and the final of the 2021 Nations League. And at youth level, their Under-19s and Under-17s had each reached at least the last four of their most recent respective Euros in 2019 (youth tournaments in 2020 and 2021 were cancelled due to the COVID-19 pandemic).

While the phrase “if it isn’t broken, don’t fix it” does spring to mind, Spanish clubs and authorities spotted an opportunity to help themselves. If all academies were more professionally run, every club could potentially stand to benefit. At the very least, the steady stream of domestic players coming through and supplying the national team would be maintained.

“We thought that we needed to do something,” says Florit. “Other countries like Germany, Austria and Sweden were starting good projects with a solid base and a long-term vision.

“[Before] there was no real collective plan, collective vision, or collective strategy to work within the academy system and to strengthen the development of young talents [across Spain].”

And while that may have been the case, the domestic contingent in La Liga was already very strong and remains as such, perhaps to a degree most won’t be fully aware of. This is their position of strength.

For the 10 seasons prior to 2026-27, the average number of Spanish players to play more than 450 minutes (so, the equivalent of five full matches) in a campaign is 236.6, a figure that dwarfs the rest of the big five leagues. The next closest is Italians in Serie A (152.2), followed by French players in Ligue 1 (149.9), Germans in the Bundesliga (142.6) and then English players in the Premier League (117.7).

The difference is massive.

While sceptics might query whether La Liga’s figures are boosted by a high concentration of domestic players playing just enough minutes to meet our arbitrary threshold, that simply isn’t the case.

The data rather emphatically proves this.

Over the same period noted above, Spanish players accounted for 57.2% of minutes played by all players in La Liga on average. And once again, the gulf to the other top leagues is enormous.

English players in the Premier League accounted for 30.5% of all minutes on average over the same timeframe; minutes by German players in the Bundesliga came to 40.7%; Italians in Serie A was 36.8%; and French in Ligue 1 was 40.1%.

This season, the difference is even starker; Spanish players account for 58.9% of minutes played in La Liga. None of the other top five European leagues even break 40%.

The importance of those figures goes beyond simple representation.

“The national team benefits when clubs not only train young players but trust them with real minutes at a high level,” he says.

And in that respect, looking specifically at giving minutes to players who are 21 or younger, La Liga has a good track record.

Over the 10 seasons prior to 2026-27, only Ligue 1 (8.2%) had a better average for proportion of minutes played by domestic players aged 21 or younger than La Liga (5.3%) among the big five European leagues.

It should also be remembered, though, that all but one of the clubs from Spain’s top two tiers have reserve teams (under-23s, essentially) who play in the same football pyramid and can climb as high as the second division; some have more than one. So even if they’re not playing for the senior team, they will be playing senior football at a lower level.

Spanish football isn’t unique for this as similar occurs in Italy, Germany and France. However, in Italy and Germany, those teams are restricted to playing in the third tier or lower; in France, many are limited to the fifth tier, while only clubs with “elite” academies can enter the fourth tier.

Florit believes Spain’s ‘B team’ system represents one of Spanish football’s biggest structural advantages.

“In Spain, 41 of the 42 professional clubs have a reserve or dependent team competing in the regular senior pyramid,” he says. “That gives young players from 17, 18, 19, 20 years old a very demanding bridge before first-team football.”

Obviously in England, for example, the most talented youngsters graduate from the age-group system fairly early. Plenty, however, will still be playing under-21 football regularly into their early 20s, which hardly feels beneficial to most. By the same age, young Spanish players could have several seasons of regular football in semi-professional (or professional) environments against both developing and experienced opposition under the belt.

There are signs that those players making the step up from reserve teams are getting younger again as well. The average age of domestic players who played 450+ La Liga minutes in 2021-22 was 28 years and 101 days, nearly a year older than the average across the other top leagues.

Last season, that was down to 27 years and 60 days, younger than both the Premier League (27 years, 68 days) and the Bundesliga (27 years, 79 days). In fact, this has decreased year on year for La Liga since the national academy plan was revealed in 2022.

The data very much supports the assertion that Spain’s youth development drive wasn’t a reaction to a negative situation. But it can’t be said this is purely down to the national academy plan.

La Liga has gone big on sustainability in recent years, with the introduction of club-specific salary caps in 2013 something of a watershed moment.

Each club’s salary cap is based on the difference between its revenue, expenses and expected debt repayments over the course of a campaign. While teams technically set their own caps, they must be validated by the body that regulates La Liga’s economic control regulations.

A team must prove compliance whenever they register a new player – if they can’t, the player cannot be registered until the club is back in the black, meaning the player is unable to play.

The idea is it promotes financial prudence and competitiveness. It’s not universally appreciated, it must be said. But while mostly associated with transfer business, there is certainly an argument it encourages clubs to extract more value from their own academies.

Clubs who’ve had financial difficulties have somewhere to turn. Valencia, for instance, have routinely dipped into their reserves over the past few years; Sevilla, who’ve now started three successive seasons with the lowest salary limit in La Liga, have had to fill out their squad with youth players, and several of them became key players. In fact, of the €41 million they raised in player sales over the summer, €21m was attributed to academy products Juanlu Sánchez (€11m to Bournemouth) and Oso (€10m to Strasbourg).

It is argued the regulations result in players being sold on the cheap, and that includes promising young Spaniards departing to foreign clubs (like the two Sevilla talents mentioned above). Most clubs agree the financial controls are a necessary evil, however.

“One of the main objectives of any football organisation is to find the balance between performance and economical sustainability,” Florit says. “We really believe in La Liga that probably the fastest and most reliable way to achieve this objective is to invest in youth and players’ development.”

Obviously there is a club focus here; there has to be considering these are club academies. But the national team(s) stand to benefit automatically. And when it comes to measuring success, La Liga very much considers the various levels of the national team as key yardsticks.

Last month La Liga pointed out that Spain have won 23 titles across senior and youth teams for men and women since the Youth Academy Meetings began in 2016, more than double any other European nation (Germany – 9, England – 7, France – 6).

Of course, the headline successes here are the men’s team’s glory at the 2026 World Cup and Euro 2024, as well as Spain’s triumph at the 2023 Women’s World Cup. But the fact they are also racking up titles at age-group level suggests the production lines are still working as desired, if not even better than before.

Spain’s success on the international scene will be under an English-lensed microscope this week given England face La Roja in the Nations League on Saturday. With the Three Lions still waiting to win a first major international title since their World Cup win in 1966 and Spain having just plundered their fifth in 18 years, glances of envy and curiosity will be shot towards Iberia.

“Why can’t we have what they have?”

England will eventually win something again in the men’s game, but will they be able to enjoy the level of success Spain have since 2008? Without a domestic top flight that provides such reliable pathways for homegrown talents, it’s easy to see why people have their doubts.

Florit is very complimentary of England’s Elite Player Performance Plan (EPPP), which was created at a similar time to the FA’s Youth Development Review, suggesting La Liga had borrowed ideas from it extensively over the years.

And the there’s little denying the Premier League is the world’s best domestic league in terms of playing standard, not to mention the wealthiest. But with all that, it makes sense that fewer homegrown players make the step up to the top league.

Obviously only the very best would get international recognition anyway, though the bigger your pool is, the more players you’re likely to have vying for contention at that level.

Perhaps, then, for all the talk of development plans, football ecosystems and methodologies, the fundamental difference maker for Spain is simply trust.

“The player is the project,” Florit adds. “Not the results, not the rankings, not the classification; the player.”

It’s a philosophy that appears ingrained for many Spanish academies. League titles at youth level certainly aren’t completely ignored, but the priority is producing players who make it professionally, whether at your club or not.

Where other countries have embarked on full-blown youth development revolutions, Spain’s academy plan is more akin to the formalisation and protection of existing pathways.

Spanish football was already very healthy when it began assessing itself; the ambition was, quite simply, to ensure it stayed that way.

Enjoy this? Subscribe to our football newsletter to receive exclusive weekly content. You should also follow our social accounts over on X, Instagram, TikTok and Facebook.

Spain Built the Youth Development Pathway England Still Crave Opta Analyst.

Hence then, the article about spain built the youth development pathway england still crave was published today ( ) and is available on The Analyst ( Middle East ) The editorial team at PressBee has edited and verified it, and it may have been modified, fully republished, or quoted. You can read and follow the updates of this news or article from its original source.

Read More Details
Finally We wish PressBee provided you with enough information of ( Spain Built the Youth Development Pathway England Still Crave )

Last updated :

Also on site :

Most Viewed News
جديد الاخبار