The public fight over yoga in San Diego city parks and at popular beaches is far from entering the final stretch. As the city and yoga teacher Steve Hubbard, known by his moniker NamaSteve, and teacher Amy Baack, are embroiled in two public court battles over whether free yoga classes should be considered a First Amendment right, Yoga instructor Hubbard has thrown yet another proverbial punch.Meanwhile, the city of San Diego is digging in its heels on the previously filed federal and state lawsuits and attempting to subpoena the financial information of the yoga practitioners who donated to Hubbard and fellow yoga instructors, in hopes of proving that the students were paying a fee for the yoga classes. On June 22, Hubbard filed a third lawsuit against the city of San Diego over the three citations issued by San Diego Park rangers to Hubbard in 2025, in the weeks following a federal court order that stated the city’s interpretation was unconstitutional. Hubbard’s lawsuit says the first of the three citations came on May 6, 2025, four months after a federal court judge ruled that the city’s ordinance, as written, “substantially overburdens speech by prohibiting any individual from providing any lecture to a group of any size on any subject in any San Diego public park or beach at any time.”On that day, rangers, according to Hubbard’s new lawsuit, cited the yoga instructor for violating the city law that bans commercial activity in public parks and at beaches. The tickets didn’t stop there.On May 24, two of the same rangers drove to Hubbard’s home and issued yet another citation, this time alleging Hubbard violated the same law when he live-streamed a yoga class from the backyard of his Pacific Beach home. Then, the following day, Hubbard received yet another ticket for teaching a class at the park for financial gain and for giving a lecture in a public park.“Even after the U.S. District Court ruled the city’s ordinance prohibiting ‘giving any lecture’ in a city park violated the First Amendment, park rangers continued citing our client for this, including going to his home and citing him for teaching yoga online because it could be viewed in a park,” said attorney Bryan Pease of Pease & Ijadi, the law firm that brought the case.As the city faces yet another lawsuit over yoga and other expressive activities in public parks, attorneys for the city are ramping up their fight against Hubbard and the practitioners who donated money to him for his classes. In newly released subpoenas, obtained by Times of San Diego, attorneys for the city are seeking to subpoena all of Hubbard’s financial records, including bank statements, Venmo and Zelle payments, social media messages, and GPS records for Hubbard and Baack, in hopes of showing the scope of Hubbard and Baack’s alleged commercial enterprise. To do so, San Diego city attorneys are also requesting the GPS records of the students who donated to Hubbard and Baack.Attorney Pease says he is asking a judge to void the subpoenas.“Now the city is going so far as to issue subpoenas to Venmo and other third parties for GPS tracking information of yoga students when they made donations, which we are moving to quash.”A San Diego Superior Court Judge will decide on whether or not to let the subpoenas move forward at a July 17 hearing. Trial in the preceding state court case is now set for January of next year. San Diego City Attorney’s Office declined to comment due to pending litigation.
Hence then, the article about the fight over free yoga in san diego parks and beaches intensifies was published today ( ) and is available on Times of San Diego ( Middle East ) The editorial team at PressBee has edited and verified it, and it may have been modified, fully republished, or quoted. You can read and follow the updates of this news or article from its original source.
Read More Details
Finally We wish PressBee provided you with enough information of ( The fight over free Yoga in San Diego parks and beaches intensifies )
Also on site :