The Prime Minister and his foreign secretary, David Lammy, wrongly assumed in Opposition, that in giving full backing to Israel’s military action to destroy Hamas’s military capability in Gaza after the horrors of the 7 October attacks two years ago, this would yield a clear and quick outcome.
The Prime Minister has followed an upward trend across France, Germany and now the UK away from “whatever it takes” rhetoric of support for Israel towards a position intended to wield pressure on the Netanyahu government for a change or course.
But the policy shift towards recognition of Palestine is a different tack to supporting more humanitarian aid or extending a welcoming hand to some 300 young Gazans in need of advanced medical treatment who will be allowed access to the NHS – in the same way that treatment rights were given to Ukrainians who have fled the fighting zones. The unspoken aim of the recognition of Palestine, alongside a genuine horror at the rise of child and infant deaths and malnutrition in Gaza, is a more vocal alignment with the Palestinian cause.
It is essentially a cry of frustration, not a policy: Israel can give ground on conceding that famine conditions in Gaza are unacceptable (even assuming it can be persuaded to drop the claim that Hamas is solely responsible for this outcome) but nothing follows from that about the viability of a two-state solution.
It means the policy is a chimera: recognising a Palestinian state without the means to create one. This is an ongoing conflict, which means that this very basic test of recognition flounders unless the two sides agree on borders or deal with the status of Jerusalem. This is a tangle of competing objectives, none of which are realisable in the near future.
What it does reflect is Starmer’s fear that fence-sitting on the Palestinian issue could endanger his government.
Talking to ministers close to the decision to support the recognition strategy, one common theme was a fear that Starmer had, as one Cabinet figure put it, “backed himself into a Blair mark 2 position”, a faultline similar to the Iraq conflict in which many people uncomfortable at the leader’s full-throated support for the invasion felt subject to a loyalty test to a commitment they did not feel comfortable about.
The heat has not come only from the left of the party, with historically pro-Palestinian connections, but also from impeccable Starmerite centrists, including Shabana Mahmood, the Justice Secretary, and Wes Streeting, the Health Secretary, both of whom are in constituencies vulnerable to pressure on the right from Reform UK and the left from Gaza-allied voters abandoning Labour.
square IAN DUNT Starmer is finally recognising Palestine - but it isn't enough
Read More
Many Jewish supporters of Labour are horrified by the images from Gaza and supportive of a push to amp up pressure for humanitarian aid to be let into the war-torn territory. But as one prominent donor observes, the tensions over the era of unaddressed antisemitism in Labour has not gone away: Starmer defined his leadership of Labour with a ruthless rout of the anti-Israel left.
The problem this stores up for Starmer is that in trying to solve one problem via the “Palestinianisation” of his outlook, he has drawn attention to a vulnerability: namely a tendency to embrace and drop positions of principle. The core Starmer belief (if there is such a thing) is that the “10 years of Labour” promise of solid electoral revival can be achieved, if Labour can avoid an internal fissure and focus on the rise of Reform.
But there are dangers in making promises which can’t be fulfilled in practice. It’s a recipe to ease tensions at home but nowhere near a durable plan for peace where it counts – in Gaza.
Anne McElvoy is co host of POLITICO/Sky TV’s podcast, Politics at Sam and Anne’s
Hence then, the article about keir starmer has now made two fundamental miscalculations about gaza was published today ( ) and is available on inews ( Middle East ) The editorial team at PressBee has edited and verified it, and it may have been modified, fully republished, or quoted. You can read and follow the updates of this news or article from its original source.
Read More Details
Finally We wish PressBee provided you with enough information of ( Keir Starmer has now made two fundamental miscalculations about Gaza )
Also on site :