With such a diverse range of options, it’s no wonder English muffins have become a cherished breakfast staple worldwide. Whether you prefer the classic version or love discovering new takes on this timeless treat, there’s an English muffin to satisfy every craving.
Related: We Tried 12 Strawberry Jams and the Winner Won By a Landslide
?? SIGN UP to get delicious recipes, handy kitchen hacks & more in our daily Pop Kitchen newsletter ??
So many choicesTheresa Greco
Thomas' muffins became especially popular in hotels, where they were served as a more refined alternative to bread or toast. Over time, the term "English muffin" became widely used in the United States to differentiate Thomas' product from American muffins, which are typically sweeter and cake-like in texture.
Related: We Made Sauce With 16 Different Canned Tomatoes and the Winner Won by a Landslide
What Sets English Muffins Apart?
To preserve this signature texture, English muffins are traditionally split with a fork rather than a knife. The rough, uneven interior allows them to better capture butter and other toppings. Using a knife would create a smoother surface, which is less effective at holding spreads.
Related: We Tried Making the Famous Olympic Village Chocolate Muffins and Now We Get the Hype
Split English muffinsTheresa Greco
Freshness Always check the expiration date or sell-by date to ensure you're buying fresh muffins. The fresher the muffin, the better the texture and flavor.Ingredients Look for muffins with simple, high-quality ingredients—flour, water, yeast, milk or buttermilk, and a pinch of salt. Avoid those with excessive preservatives, artificial colors or sweeteners. Quality ingredients make a big difference in taste.Signature Texture (Nooks and Crannies) One of the trademarks of a good English muffin is its rough, uneven interior—those beloved nooks and crannies. This isn't something you can really check before buying, but when you split them at home, you want to see that airy, open crumb that's perfect for holding butter, jam, or toppings.Brand Reputation Some well-known brands, like Thomas', have established a reputation for quality, but don’t be afraid to try other brands or options from local bakeries. Sometimes, smaller or store-brand English muffins surprise you with great flavor and texture.
Related: We Tried 10 Aldi Coffees and the Winner Tastes Way More Expensive Than It Is
How We Tested These English Muffins
Parade
While we know that popular brands offer various options (such as whole wheat, multi-grain, or gluten-free), we focused on classic or original varieties for this test to keep the comparison fair and consistent. By the end of this ranking, you’ll know which classic English muffin takes the crown, making it easier than ever to choose the best one for your morning routine.
Related: The 8 Best Store-Bought Whole-Grain Breads, According to Dietitians
English muffin tasting dayTheresa Greco
10 Popular English Muffin Brands, Ranked Worst to Best
10. Panera Bread Classic English Muffins
Panera BreadTheresa Greco
What stood out more, however, was the texture. It was denser and doughier than some of the other muffins we sampled, lacking the classic "nooks and crannies" that help absorb butter and toppings. This made the muffin feel more substantial, but also heavier and less light and airy.
Related: We Tried 10 Instant Oatmeals and You Can Buy the Winner at Walmart
9. Wildgrain Artisan English Muffins
WildgrainTheresa Greco
Unfortunately, the muffins lacked the signature airy pockets we've all come to expect from English muffins. That said, the team agreed they did offer a satisfying and tasty experience. Overall, I’d definitely recommend giving their products a try.
8. Whole Foods Market 365 Classic English Muffins
Whole Foods Market 365Theresa Greco
Priced at $4 for a pack of four, they're on par price-wise with other mainstream brands. However, their high-quality, natural ingredients make them a good option for those seeking a more wholesome alternative.
7. English 'Em Muffins English Muffins
English EM MuffinsTheresa Greco
While the flavor was mild and pleasant, the overall texture of EM muffins left the team with mixed impressions. One notable difference was the absence of the signature "split" that allows for a clean, even slice. Instead, these muffins are a bit uneven when cut through, leading to irregular halves.
Related: 23 Must-Buy Aldi Snacks, According to a Superfan
6. Dave's Killer Bread Classic English Muffins
Dave's Killer BreadTheresa Greco
Overall, Dave's Killer Classic English Muffins are a great choice for anyone looking for a healthier muffin option that doesn’t compromise on flavor, offering a satisfying and guilt-free indulgence.
5. Oroweat Extra Crisp English Muffins
OroweatTheresa Greco
The muffins toasted evenly and delivered the classic English muffin flavor you'd expect. Made with whole grains, Oroweat English Muffins also offer a good source of fiber, with 5 grams per serving. We enjoyed them and agreed they’re a reliable and solid choice.
4. Great Value Original English Muffins
Great ValueTheresa Greco
Related: We Asked Dietitians to Rank 10 Popular Canned Tunas and You Can Buy the Winner at Walmart
3. Thomas' Original English Muffins
Thomas'Theresa Greco
Additionally, the traditional fork-split method ensures a surface that toasts beautifully, adding to the eating experience. As a brand synonymous with the term "English muffin," Thomas’ offers a classic choice that’s ideal for breakfast or any meal.
2. Bays Original English Muffins
BaysTheresa Greco
Despite that, the flavor balance when toasted is still exceptional, and some tasters even called them amazing. It's easy to see why Bay's muffins have earned their place as a staple in my household!
Related: I Tried 12 Canned Biscuits and the Winner Won by a Landslide
1. Rudi's Organic English Muffins
Rudi'sTheresa Greco
The muffins were noted to be slightly thinner than some other brands, but this was seen as a positive. Overall, the team had nothing but good things to say, enjoying the wholesome and well-balanced taste. In addition to the classic variety, Rudi’s also offers gluten-free options, which the tasters appreciated.
Related: We Ranked 12 Olive Oil Brands and You Can Buy the Winner at Whole Foods
Hence then, the article about we tried 10 popular english muffin brands and found a new favorite was published today ( ) and is available on Parade ( Saudi Arabia ) The editorial team at PressBee has edited and verified it, and it may have been modified, fully republished, or quoted. You can read and follow the updates of this news or article from its original source.
Read More Details
Finally We wish PressBee provided you with enough information of ( We Tried 10 Popular English Muffin Brands and Found a New Favorite )
Also on site :
- Large plume of smoke visible from I-290 billows from west suburban building fire
- TCPC Deadline: TCPC Investors with Losses in Excess of $100K Have Opportunity to Lead BlackRock TCP Capital Corp. Securities Fraud Lawsuit
- The Walmart billionaires next door: Quiet backlash is brewing against the heirs who remade the retailer’s hometown